Tuesday, April 17, 2012

TWD - Lemon Loaf Cake

I've never met a pound cake that I didn't love, until I met this one. I tried to love it, I really did. And I know it's not technically a pound cake, but I don't think anyone now and days makes a real pound cake. But these types of cakes are generally referred to as pound cakes. I think it's even referenced in the recipe as having a similar texture as a pound cake.

But it was not meant to be, I just didn't love it. I'm not sure I even liked it. And before you ask, no, I didn't follow the recipe. So some of the love lost could be my fault. I used Meyer lemon zest instead of regular lemons and I used full fat yogurt instead of the heavy cream. (I made these changes because those were the ingredients I had in the house and forgot it was baking Tuesday.) But come on folks those aren't heartbreaking substitutions. IF anything it should have made it more lovable. MORE LOVABLE.

It was a lemon cake for pete's sake, I should have loved it. I'm so sad now.

Plastic wrapped sadness.

But as it sits on my counter wrapped in plastic wrap, I ponder why was I not in love with this? Well take a look at the original recipe posted here and here and then I'll give you my list of reasons.
  1. It was dry, I baked it 10 minutes less than the recipe called for and it was still dry.
  2. Not enough salt, salt provides contrast and this was lacking the contrast.
  3. Not lemony enough, I had added zest from 5 Meyer lemons and still no go. It needed the juice to really give it some lemon flavor. The juice probably would've helped the dryness too.
  4. I think my tastes have changed, this might have been something I would have enjoyed in the past, but I think my taste buds (Phil and Gladys) have grown and enjoy more complex flavors. I think they bought the Emeril slogan and like to kick it up a notch.  
Oh well, love at first bite is not on the calendar for this Tuesday. Maybe the next....


  1. Bummer that you didn't like or love this one. Glad you tried it though!

    1. Me too, you never know until you try!

  2. I added juice - it did not help. I did not care for this one either.

    1. Well, i guess all the recipes aren't winners for everyone. But the next two sound really great though.

  3. Sorry it wasn't love - hopefully, there was least a little bit of like somewhere in there...